Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 56:50 — 26.1MB)
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Deezer | RSS | More
In this episode, we discuss the implications of Foundationalism and Coherentism as theories of knowledge. We explore the need for confidence in our knowledge and beliefs and how Foundationalism can help us establish this confidence. This leads to an interesting conversation about rhetoric, belief systems, and the interpretation of texts such as the Constitution and the Bible. We also touch on mental health, trauma, and the challenges of Coherentism in understanding psychological conditions. Finally, we discuss the regress argument as a strong reason to reject Coherentism and embrace Foundationalism.
We discuss:
- Distinguishing between the two kinds of Foundationalism: internalist and externalist.
- How we should understand the strong and weak (or moderate) versions of Foundationalism
- The importance of the distinction between rational certainty versus psychological certainty.
- What Coherentism is and how we see this understanding of our ability to access truth in society
- Challenges in distinguishing between mental health and illness in a Coherentist view
- The Regress Argument: Why Foundationalism is the most viable view of our access to truth.
Resources mentioned:
- Series Episode 1: How Do You Know? Are You Sure? Epistemology – Episode 52
- Series Episode 2: Who Wants to Live a Lie? Epistemology 2 – Episode 53 – Thinking Christianly
- Series Episode 3: Who and What Can We Trust? Epistemology 3 – Episode 54 – Thinking Christianly
- Philosophy Made Slightly Less Difficult: A Beginner’s Guide to Life’s Big Questions, Garrett J. DeWeese and J.P. Moreland (the chapter on epistemology)
- Philosophical Foundations for a Christian Worldview, J.P. Moreland and William Lane Craig (the chapter on epistemology)
Chapters
00:00 Understanding Epistemology: Foundations and Importance
03:34 Exploring Foundationalism: The Basis of Knowledge
22:18 Coherentism: A Different Approach to Truth
29:41 The Implications of Coherentism in Society
32:17 Understanding Dog Whistles in Rhetoric
34:37 Foundationalism vs. Positivist Law
39:36 The Nature of Community and Interpretation
41:49 Coherentism and Mental Health
50:29 The Regress Argument for Foundationalism